June 30, 2023
What is global consistency?
Global consistency refers to the process that employers use to achieve the goal of ensuring that all employees have the same benefits experience regardless of residence or work location.
Why develop a global consistency strategy?
The world is more intertwined than ever, and employee benefits strategies have no borders. Also, the workforce is becoming more mobile, requiring company leadership to have a truly global view. To retain and recruit diverse employees in today’s hypercompetitive labor market, it’s important to prioritize closing gaps in coverage while effectively managing costs and maneuvering through local obstacles.
A global consistency approach is also a key driver and facilitator to a stronger governance structure. Governance is not easy to define, but basically, it means developing and managing consistent cohesive policies, processes and decisions for a given area of responsibility.1 With the absence of governance to guide the journey of global consistency, decision-making may vary across countries or regions, resulting in inconsistent global policies and practices at the local level. A Business Group on Health governance survey found most participants stated that their governance structure covers:2
The top reasons for implementing a global governance structure include2:
A best practice governance model can build consistency across the globe in the delivery of benefit programs. Some governance best practices are to1:
- Have central access to data and market information on global benefits programs, especially for programs outside the market norm, such as fertility treatment, gender affirmation services and critical illness coverage. The data collection process requires ensuring that your broker/consultant know your global strategy and key priorities and defines how they can support you in collecting and retaining this critical information.
- Develop well-defined risk management policies, including an operating model with roles and responsibilities defined at the local, regional and corporate levels.
- Conduct formal audits to ensure that local benefits are aligned with global policies.
- Align benefit programs with overall workforce strategy.
Guiding Principles in Articulating and Managing a Global Consistency Strategy
When developing a global consistency strategy, it’s helpful to identify overarching guiding principles that can create buy-in to gain alignment. Another important element of a global strategy is understanding cultural applicability and local nuances in programs, as well as gaps between desired programs and the social system. Recognizing that some benefits provided outside the U.S. are framed significantly by government regulations and statute is crucial as well.
Marco Diaz, SVP, Global Head of Benefits, aligned News Corp’s global benefits strategy to create areas of opportunity across four key categories:
- Global Synergies – One global program across all businesses and regions (e.g., global resiliency program);
- Global Consistency – Benefit category is accounted for but may have a different vendor or benefits level (e.g., life insurance);
- Regional Relevance – Programs exist only in one particular country or region based on country norms (e.g., meal vouchers); and
- Business Unit Based – Unique programs that individual businesses have developed either to be market competitive, past precedent, or union agreements.
A glaring example of variability in benefits worldwide is global leave, where the U.S. lags behind the rest of the world in paid leave for parents. Besides Papua New Guinea, the U.S. is the only country in the world with no government mandated policy guaranteeing maternity leave.3 Of the world’s richest 41 countries, the U.S. is one of 15 that does not offer any paternity leave.3
Maternity, paternity and parental leaves vary greatly across countries. While it may not be realistic to create a global consistency strategy that mimics Estonia’s 82 plus weeks, it may be within reach to develop a company standard at a level that lets you achieve a minimum that can adjust upward over time while taking local nuances into consideration.3
This variation in length of leave across the world is one example of how each country offers a different benefit, an important factor to consider as companies look to create consistency within their approach.
The top factors to think through when managing your strategy include:
- Reinforcement of the company’s health and well-being strategy: Whether viewed as an equity issue or a business imperative to attract, retain and move talent, a global consistency strategy can strengthen a company’s commitment to a culture of health and well-being in today’s race for talent.
- Alignment with company mission, values and Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) priorities: Evaluate if your benefits support the company’s commitment to being a great place to work and align with external efforts to support the broader communities where employees live.
- Track and evaluate equity for employees: Reaching health equity and ensuring an inclusive experience for all employees may not mean the same benefits and approach for everyone. It will likely require a variety of benefits for the many situations employees face. Making benefits equitable may not mean that everyone has the same benefits, since equity looks different for everyone.
- Seamless global mobility: Support the mobility needs of your workforce by developing and maintaining a worldwide standard level of benefits, especially in medical coverage.
- Protection against catastrophic financial loss: Review gaps in or lack of benefits, such as life insurance or critical illness coverage. These programs can vary considerably from country to country, and gaps could leave employees and/or their dependents in a dire financial situation.
- Identifying opportunities for efficiencies as you deploy across the globe: In reviewing your benefits and vendors, work with your broker/consultant to see if financing mechanisms or vendor consolidation would create efficiencies to fund coverage gaps; enable purchasing power to impact the market with benefit design; and scale global consistency strategy efforts.
More TopicsArticles & Guides Value-Based Care
- 1 | Business Group on Health. Global benefits governance guide. April 21, 2022. https://www.businessgrouphealth.org/resources/global-benefits-governance-guide. Accessed May 5, 2023.
- 2 | Business Group on Health. Quick survey findings: Global benefits governance. October 14, 2021. https://www.businessgrouphealth.org/resources/quick-survey-findings-global-benefits-governance. Accessed May 5, 2023.
- 3 | Chzhen Y, Gromada A, Rees G. Are the world’s richest countries family friendly. UNICEF. June 2019. https://www.unicef.org/media/55696/file/Family-friendly%20policies%20research%202019.pdf. Accessed May 5, 2023.
IntroCreating a Globally Consistent Benefits Strategy
Part 1What Is Global Consistency, and Why Is It Important?
Part 2Harnessing Long-Term Global Consistency Opportunities
Part 3Benefits to Include in a Global Consistency Strategy
Part 4Utilizing Financing Mechanisms to Implement a Global Consistency Strategy
Part 5Prioritizing and Advancing a Globally Consistent Vision